"The talented cast is truly an ensemble... Special kudos to Brian Berendts and Alyson Snyder, who each voice and handle two major puppet roles and manage to make them quite different. Snyder is so effective at changing her voice from Kate Monster to the sexy role of Lucy the Slut that you have to search the stage in order to find the origin of that sultry voice." - Laurel Humes, League of Cincinnati Theatres (LCT).
"The production has a cast of able singers and actors who have learned their way around making puppets laugh-out-loud funny, especially Alyson Snyder as nice girl Kate Monster and neighborhood bad girl Lucy the Slut. A fine and varied singer, Snyder ably flips the switch between Kate's naive innocence and Lucy's lascivious come-hither ways, often in the same scene." - Rick Pender's STAGE DOOR, CityBeat.com
"Alyson Snyder is great as Kate Monster - muppet and actress share short hair and a youthful enthusiasm... The cast gets a shout out for professionalism and anonymity." - Kenneth Stern, League of Cincinnati Theatres (LCT).
"The cast was solid with strong performances throughout... The music seemed louder than the singers, with the exception of Alyson Snyder, an extremely apt actor and singer, in the role of Kate Monster." - Lissa Urriquia Gapultos, League of Cincinnati Theatres (LCT).